What About CAPTCHA?

comments edit

I mentioned several heuristic approachs to blocking spam in my recent post on blocking comment spam, but commenters note that I failed to mention CAPTCHA (Completely Automated Public Turing test to tell Computers and Humans Apart).  At the moment, CAPTCHA is quite effective, both at blocking spam and annoying users.

But I don’t have any real beef with CAPTCHA, apart from the accessibility issues.  If I met CAPTCHA in a bar, I’d buy it a beer! No hard feelings despite thetrash talkingin the past, right?

There is successful code out there that can break CAPTCHA, but that is pretty much true of every other method of blocking spam I’ve mentioned.

The reason I didn’t mention CAPTCHA is that it would be ineffective for me.  Much of my spam comes in via automated means such as a trackback/pingback .  The whole point of a trackback is to allow another computer to post a comment on my site.  So telling a computer apart from a human in that situation is pointless.

And at the moment, the Comment API has no support for CAPTCHA.  If comment spam isn’t coming in via the comment api now, it is only a matter of time before it is the primary source of comments.

So while I believe CAPTCHA is effective and may well be for a good while until comment spammers catch up, I would like to look one step ahead and focus on heuristics that can salvage the use of trackbacks and the Comment API. 

Comments